Question: I am seeking to reduce my equity requirement for a new development project, by adding a subordinate level of debt in addition to the primary mortgage - what are some of my alternatives?
Previous ArticlesMy parents own a vacant 8 acre parcel of land that they want to sell to an abutting institution that has continually expressed interest over the years. How can they best identify and maximize the potential value, in order to negotiate from a position of strength with the institution?
What are the types of prepayment penalty options I will encounter when financing a commercial property?
Why is project development financing becoming more expensive and difficult to secure, often requiring a higher equity contribution?
I am seeking to reduce my equity requirement for a new development project, by adding a subordinate level of debt in addition to the primary mortgage - what are some of my alternatives?
I own a building that is fully occupied by my business with a small SBA 504 loan balance. I want to refinance the building and take out some of my equity, what is my best approach to a lender?
What differentiates a commercial and residential mortgage broker?
I have been approached by a developer, who represents that the General Services Administration (GSA), is interested in a build-to-suit building for a US government agency on a parcel of land that I own. The developer also claims that we can leverage the property using the GSA lease, financing all of the project costs plus the land. Can this be accomplished?
How do increasing interest rates affect commercial real estate loan activity?
I am in the process of permitting a large condominium development; can you provide some phasing direction that will assist with the project financing?
I am a single-family homebuilder and have an opportunity to acquire a parcel of land that can be approved for a 20,000-square-foot office/warehouse building that I would like to build, lease out and retain for long-term investment. What will I need to convince a lender that this project is a good investment and worthy of financing?
I am an owner of a small manufacturing business, currently renting a building and want to acquire a new building. Is the SBA 504 program a good financing match for me?
|
| Commercial Notes is a periodic publication of articles written by professionals at Eaton Partners, Inc. directed toward answering typically asked questions on the financing, leasing, acquisition, disposition and overall ownership of commercial real estate. |
Answer: Your goal is to seek what the mortgage banking industry commonly calls “structured financing”. Two of the most common methods through which structured financing is accomplished, are mezzanine and preferred equity loans and there are numerous sources of capital, that have made these two alternatives readily available to borrowers.
For example, let’s assume that the project being developed costs $5 million. The primary or senior mortgage lender is limiting the senior loan amount to 80% of appraised value or 85% of cost whichever is less. The appraised value of the completed project is over $6 million therefore the senior loan amount is limited to 85% of cost requiring $750,000. There is $250,000 available to invest in the project and a need to borrow the additional $500,000 to meet the senior lenders requirements. Either a mezzanine or preferred equity loan can accomplish the structured financing goal.
Mezzanine debt is best defined as an additional layer or level of debt in addition and subordinate to the senior mortgage, which is not secured by the project itself, but by the developer’s equity interest in the project. A mezzanine lender will agree to loan the required subordinate debt secured by an assignment of the developer’s ownership equity interest in the project. If the mezzanine loan repayment terms are not met, the mezzanine lender can step into the developer’s shoes to satisfy repayment, converting the developer’s ownership interest to that of the mezzanine lender.
Mezzanine debt is much more expensive than senior debt and is generally available at an Internal Rate of Return “IRR” of 12%-15%. It sometimes will be priced at a greater cost predicated upon the perceived project risk by the mezzanine lender. Oftentimes, the overall yield to the mezzanine lender will be comprised of an upfront point(s), an interest rate charge that is paid during the term of the loan and an exit fee when the loan is repaid. A mezzanine loan usually carries a very definitive time line for repayment.
Preferred equity is another alternative for structured financing. A preferred equity lender receives their yield comprised of an agreed upon split of the project’s future cash flow (profit) plus a preferred interest rate paid on the equity invested. The interest rate payment is preferential and must be paid before any cash flow or profits can be distributed to the developer. The preferred equity lender is also secured by the developer’s ownership equity. IRR requirements on preferred equity are usually greater than mezzanine debt, typically between 15%-20%.
There are many alternatives to structuring the split on future cash flow for a preferred equity loan, but a widely accepted method is named the “IRR Look Back”. Assume that the preferred equity lender and the developer agree to a 17% IRR, with an interest pay rate of 8% and a 60% sharing of the cash flow. Since the amount of cash flow received from the lender’s 60% share will fluctuate based upon the project cash flow, there is a look back provision guaranteeing the 17% IRR. Before the developer can take any additional cash flows other than the 40% split, the 17% IRR must be paid to the lender.
The major difference between the two alternatives is that mezzanine debt carries a higher interest payment schedule, not contingent upon project cash flow. Preferred equity on the other hand, allows a lower interest payment, but requires a split of the cash flows with the developer to arrive at the required yield. The preferred equity structure typically allows the developer to receive earlier project cash flows in return for a greater yield to the lender.
Eaton Partners, Inc. • 814 Elm Street • Manchester, NH 03101
(603) 626-1964 |
